科研之友
微信
新浪微博
Facebook
分享链接
摘要
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSETo determine the interobserver reliability of a newly proposed classification scheme for angiographic classification of spinal vascular malformations including arteriovenous fistulas (AVFs) and arteriovenous malformations (AVMs).
METHODA study was performed done in which 1-2 representative angiographic images of 26 spinal AVFs and/or AVMs were independently classified by five fellows in the ACGME accredited Endovascular Surgical Neuroradiology (ESN) program and two external interventionalists in the absence of any other clinical or imaging data. From these observations the interobserver reliability for each category and the overall scheme were determined in terms of the median weighted kappa statistic.
RESULTSThe overall interobserver reliability for the new classification scheme was a Kappa of 0.53 (Z= 21.3, P= <.0001) among the seven raters. The Kappa for individual grades was as follows: grade I (k= 0.66), grade II (k= 0.50), grade III (k= 0.44), and grade IV (k= 0.58). Three or more raters agreed on 100% of the cases. The interobserver reliability was high among the two practicing interventionalist raters (k= 0.55, 95% confidence interval 0.3-0.8). The interobserver reliability remained high among junior ESN fellows (k= 0.65).
CONCLUSIONThe new classification scheme provided satisfactory reliability even in the hands of less experienced observers. The scheme can be used with minimal training and other concurrent data and can be relied upon to provide consistent results.
- 出版日期2013-7
