Assessing the Concreteness of Relational Representation

作者：Rein Jonathan R; Markman Arthur B^*

来源：Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition , 2010, 36(6): 1452-1465.

DOI：10.1037/a0021040

• knowledge representation
• abstraction
• similarity
• analogy

Research has shown that people's ability to transfer abstract relational knowledge across situations can be heavily influenced by the concrete objects that fill relational roles. This article provides evidence that the concreteness of the relations themselves also affects performance. In 3 experiments, participants viewed simple relational patterns of visual objects and then identified these same patterns under a variety of physical transformations. Results show that people have difficulty generalizing to novel concrete forms of abstract relations, even when objects are unchanged. This suggests that stimuli are initially represented as concrete relations by default. In the 2nd and 3rd experiments, the number of distinct concrete relations in the training set was increased to promote more abstract representation. Transfer improved for novel concrete relations but not for other transformations such as object substitution. Results indicate that instead of automatically learning abstract relations, people's relational representations preserve all properties that appear consistently in the learning environment, including concrete objects and concrete relations.

• 出版日期2010-11