Historical perspective on the use of visual grading scales in evaluating skin irritation and sensitization

作者：Farage Miranda A^*; Maibach Howard I; Andersen Klaus E; Lachapelle Jean Marie; Kern Petra; Ryan Cindy; Ely Jeanne; Kanti Amita

来源：Contact Dermatitis, 2011, 65(2): 65-75.

DOI：10.1111/j.1600-0536.2011.01912.x

• contact dermatitis
• grading erythema
• patch testing
• skin irritation
• visual assessment

Visual assessment of skin reactions has long been used to evaluate the safety of chemicals and preparations that contact the skin, and to meet regulatory requirements. This article reviews the history of visual grading scales, and the results of investigations into the reliability of the method. Some examples are provided to illustrate the diverse array of protocols that use visual scoring to evaluate skin irritation. Furthermore, as bioengineering methods are developed that can quantitate certain aspects of skin irritant and sensitization reactions, it is important to consider whether such measures should supplement or replace visual assessment. Examples of investigations comparing the outcomes of studies that use visual scoring and those that use bioengineering methods are discussed. These examples provide little evidence that bioengineering measures provide an improvement in overall quality in comparison with current testing methods that rely on visual assessment. In addition, such measuring techniques can add considerably to the complexity of testing protocols. When benefits and cost are weighed in the balance, the visual assessment scales popularized by Draize and others remain an effective, practical method of evaluation.

• 出版日期2011