Discordance with 3 Cardiac Troponin I and T Assays: Implications for the 99th Percentile Cutoff

作者：Ungerer Jacobus Petrus Johannes^*; Tate Jillian Russyll; Pretorius Carel Jacobus

来源：Clinical Chemistry, 2016, 62(8): 1106-1114.

DOI：10.1373/clinchem.2016.255281

BACKGROUND: We compared the 99th percentile reference intervals with 3 modern cardiac troponin assays in a single cohort and tested the hypothesis that the same individuals will be identified as above the cutoff and that differences will be explained by analytical imprecision.
METHODS: Blood was collected from 2005 apparently healthy blood donors. Cardiac troponin was measured with Abbott Architect STAT high sensitive troponin I, Beckman Coulter Access AccuTnI + 3, and Roche Elecsys troponin T highly sensitive assays.
RESULTS: The 99th percentile cutoff limits were as follows: Abbott cardiac troponin I (cTnI) 28.9 ng/L; Beckman Coulter cTnI 31.3 ng/L; and Roche cardiac troponin T (cTnT) 15.9 ng/L. Correlation among the assays was poor: Abbott cTnI vs Beckman Coulter cTnI, R-2 = 0.18; Abbott cTnI vs Roche cTnT, R-2 = 0.04; and Beckman Coulter cTnI vs Roche cTnT R-2 = 0.01. Of the results above the cutoff 50% to 70% were unique to individual assays, with only 4 out of 20 individuals above the cutoff for all 3 assays. The observed differences among assays were larger than predicted from analytical imprecision.
CONCLUSIONS: The 99th percentile cutoff values were in agreement with those reported elsewhere. The poor correlation and concordance amongst the assays were notable. The differences found could not be explained by analytical imprecision and indicate the presence of inaccuracy (bias) that is unique to sample and assay combinations. Based on these findings we recommend less emphasis on the cutoff value and greater emphasis on delta values in the diagnosis of myocardial infarction.

• 出版日期2016-8