How temporal and spatial aspects of presenting visualizations affect learning about locomotion patterns

作者：Imhof Birgit^*; Scheiter Katharina; Edelmann Joerg; Gerjets Peter

来源：Learning and Instruction, 2012, 22(3): 193-205.

DOI：10.1016/j.learninstruc.2011.10.006

• Learning
• Dynamic visualizations
• Sequentiality of multiple static visualizations
• Spatial layout of static-simultaneous visualizations
• Visuospatial abilities

Two studies investigated the effectiveness of dynamic and static visualizations for a perceptual learning task (locomotion pattern classification). In Study 1, seventy-five students viewed either dynamic, static-sequential, or static-simultaneous visualizations. For tasks of intermediate difficulty, dynamic visualizations led to better classification performance than static-sequential visualizations, but not than static-simultaneous visualizations. To test whether the temporal aspects of presenting static-simultaneous visualizations (i.e., their permanent visibility) or their spatial aspects (i.e., their arrangement in rows) accounted for this effect, Study 2 investigated three additional static-simultaneous conditions. Seventy-five students viewed static-simultaneous visualizations presented either in columns, matrices, or circles. For tasks of intermediate difficulty dynamic visualizations outperformed pictures presented in columns, matrices, and circles, but not the rows format. Accordingly, for learning about locomotion patterns, dynamic visualizations are better suited than most, but not all static visualization formats. From a practical point of view, effort should be invested into the design of static-simultaneous visualizations to further optimize instructional materials.

• 出版日期2012-6